Paiva Realty GroupThe Perrino Team
Listed Sep 10, 2026 · 71 days on market
1 of 46

1232 Pilot Hill Road

Block Island, RI 02807 · Washington County

$2,525,000

$1,174/sqft

Active

3

Beds

2

Baths

2,150

Sq Ft

1985

Year Built

$1,174/sqft

Price/Sqft

About This Home

Set on 2.91 acres in the scenic Pilot Hill area of Block Island, this beautifully maintained home offers a private Island setting surrounded by rolling meadows, mature trees, and one of Block Island’s iconic freshwater ponds. Ideally located between Old Harbor and the Mohegan Bluffs, the property feels peaceful and removed while remaining convenient to town, beaches, and Island amenities. The light filled home offers comfortable Island living with an open floor plan, hardwood floors, spacious bedrooms, updated baths, and expansive decks overlooking the surrounding landscape. Large windows bring the outdoors in, filling the home with natural light and showcasing the peaceful setting. The generous 2.91 acre lot is an important part of the property’s value. Located in the RA Zone, the size of the parcel allows for a substantially larger building footprint than the existing residence currently occupies, offering meaningful expansion potential while preserving the privacy and open space of the property. In addition to its appeal as a private Island retreat, the home has a strong and successful rental history, adding another dimension to its value and providing an established opportunity for rental income. With its expansive grounds, freshwater pond setting, successful rental history, and potential for a larger footprint, this is a distinctive Block Island property offering both immediate enjoyment and long term possibilities.

Property Details

Property TypeSingle Family Residence
MLS #1422981
Lot Size2.91 acres
Garage Spaces0
Stories2
Days on Market71
WaterfrontNo
HOANo
2025 Taxes$5,428.8
Assessed Value$1,396,800
Tax Map #8
Tax Lot194-2

Heating

OilForced Air

Cooling

Central Air

Our estimate, not part of the MLS listing

Estimated monthly cost

$14,969/mo

  • Principal & interest

    30-year at 7.25%, estimated rate

    $13,780

  • Property tax

    2025 tax bill (State-Wide MLS)

    $452

  • Homeowners insurance

    Estimate: the greater of $1,400/yr or 0.35% of price

    $737

  • Total

    $14,969/mo

Checking the FEMA flood map…

%
%

Term

$/yr

Rate: estimate (the current Freddie Mac weekly average couldn't be loaded)

First-time buyer? See RIHousing's homebuyer programs

Plan Your Purchase

Estimate only, not a loan offer. Taxes, insurance and rates vary.

Map and nearby listings

Open in map search →
Loading map…

MLS IDX

Courtesy of: Lila Delman Compass · Rosemary TOBIN · (401) 741-1825

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. © 2026 State-Wide Multiple Listing Service. All rights reserved.

Presented by Paiva Realty Group · The Perrino Team · (401) 206-8907

SP

Stephen Perrino

Paiva Realty Group

The Perrino Team

First-time buyer? Learn about buyer representation →

Schedule a Showing

Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Call Agent